An Ocean’s Edict: Blinkist Summaries Are Blah, Show Me the Tidbits

While vigorously researching the book summary marketplace, I happened upon one Olga Khazan’s article (from The Atlantic) where she provided more anecdotal confirmation that my book summaries don’t work theory is RIGHT:

In Blinkist, meanwhile, even the final “key messages” section contained points that were far too vague and reductivist:

Moreover, she struck my Notevantage chords multiple times. Check these selections out:

I was curious to see how either Blinkist or Wikipedia would handle anecdotes, the glue that holds all the cocktail-party nuggets of nonfiction books together.

Wikipedia avoids any and all human-interest tidbits. I kept waiting for a glimmer of Cain’s story of how Steve Wozniak’s introversion helped him—and Apple—ascend the early computing world.

Now granted Notevantage is completely RANDOM (thus far) but if non-fiction book tidbits (and great, practical ones at that) is what you seek then that is what ye shall get here.

Here’s some more confirmation bias from the blogosphere:

Scott from ScottHYoung.com says:

because summary-level knowledge is common, you can get a competitive advantage by having read works in greater depth. Knowing a few things to a deeper level might make up for having greater, broad summary-level knowledge

Will from WillYouLaugh.com writes:

Book summary companies are often in the game of making money. They’re incentivized to tell you that book summaries are the holy grail. If I had to choose between the guy who’s read 1000+ book summaries and the guy who has deeply studied a solid selection of 100 books, I’d choose the latter.

And of course you’ve seen my extremely biased theory on why book summaries are 85% garbage, 15% ok, fine they’re not the scum of the earth.

The post An Ocean’s Edict: Blinkist Summaries Are Blah, Show Me the Tidbits appeared first on Notevantage.

from Notevantage https://notevantage.com/oceans-edict-blinkist-summaries-blah-show-me-tidbits/

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s